Broker Pricing

What motivates a broker to price a business too low?

Started by TundraSundae • November 02, 2026 • 12 replies
TundraSundae

I'm getting ready to list my business and keep hearing horror stories about brokers underpricing. Not trying to lose money here. What actually drives a broker to set a low asking price? Is it laziness, strategy, or something else?

GrumpyBeaver77

Quick sale = quick commission. That's it. They'd rather churn a $500k sale tomorrow than grind for a $700k sale in six months.

MintyPinecone

I don't think it's laziness so much as risk management on their end. A low price attracts more buyers, creates a bidding war, and they look like heroes. Plus they're not the ones losing the extra $100k.

RustyAnchor

Or it's just incompetence. My last broker priced my laundromat based on a generic industry multiplier witthout even looking at my lease terms. Sold for way less than I wanted.

GrumpyBeaver77

Yeah but you still sold, didn't you? Broker got paid. That's the whole point.

TundraSundae

So how do you counter this? Do you just push back on their valuation or is it better to get multiple opinions?

MintyPinecone

Get three brokers to value it. If two come in higher, the lowballer either adjusts or you walk. Also make them show comps. Real ones. Not their cousin's bar that sold in 2019.

SlinkyOtter

Some brokers lowball intentionally because it makes them look like a dealmaker. They know the buyer will negotiate up anyway. So the $400k list price turns into a $475k sale snd everyone claps. It's theater.

GrumpyBeaver77

Theater is generous. I call it 'anchor to the bottom' pricing. And it works because most sellers are desperate.

RustyAnchor

Desperate or tired. By the time you're listing, you've already checked out mentally. Easy to get pushed around.

TundraSundae

So the consensus is basically 'trust no one, do your own homework.' Fair enough. What about brokers who are honest — how do you spoot them? Or is that a unicorn hunt?

SlinkyOtter

They exist. Look for someone who asks more questions than they answer. If they're trying to understand your business before quoting a number, that's a good sign. If they slap a price on it in ten minutes, run

MintyPinecone

Also check if they have a hidden double-dip — like they represent buyrs too on the same deal. Conflict of interest baked in.

Join the conversation

Log in or register to reply to this discussion.